|
jasmine .
{K:626} 7/23/2005
|
i prefer this version, colors add life, especially skin tones, it brings out the glow. But thats just my personal preference.
|
|
|
Del Metheny
{K:25617} 6/27/2005
|
I know I am not always agreed with on this, but when filming live subjects, be it people or plants, I much prefer color. There are times when trying to create a mood or using subdued lighting B/W does work better but in a case like this where it is a straight forward portrait I vote for the color. Del
|
|
|
Mike Middendorffi
{K:371} 6/25/2005
|
This one. . .nice pose, arrangement and angle but the lighting doesn't work extremely well. Our subject is somewhat in the dark. . nice hopeful upcast expression though. . .
|
|
|
patrizio napolitano
{K:13119} 6/22/2005
|
good portrait and very beautiful the model's expression interesting the effect 3D the colors are very beautiful patrizio
|
|
|
Len Webster
{K:25714} 5/28/2005
|
I like the way there is more light on the face - the fact that the head is turned and the eyes are looking into the distance adds to the overall effect. Nice balance of colour.
|
|
|
Margaret Sturgess
{K:49403} 5/13/2005
|
Sally I like the colour version more, it has good tones and they show up better in the colour version. The BW is perhaps not quite strong enough tones, but I am no expert anyway - but particularly in BW. Although I am at the moment trying a few conversions of shots of my grandaughter. Margaret
|
|
|
Shoot Mike
{K:3255} 4/27/2005
|
Email me. mcollins@ota.state.ok.us
|
|
|
Sally Morgan
{K:9219} 4/27/2005
|
Hi Mike - thanks for taking the time to comment honestly! I'm not so hot on B&W - so when you say it doesn't have enough contrast, - does that mean that it has potential to be re-tweaked in PS - or that I should look for a more suitable image to start with? And do you have any tips for B&W conversion? Thank you, Sally.
|
|
|
Shoot Mike
{K:3255} 4/27/2005
|
Sally,
You have a nice model. I think the color is a better photograph. The b&w doesn't have enough contrast to make it a good b&w. The soft colors of her shirt and color of her hair make the color better for me. A dab of powder on her face would help with the slight shine of her skin also.
Mike
|
|
|
Bryan Jarmain
{K:11941} 4/21/2005
|
Sally, a great composition, nicely taken. Having eye contact would have probably made a stronger shot, but very good all the same.
|
|
|
Sally Morgan
{K:9219} 4/21/2005
|
I have a really neat attachment for my camera hot shoe - it's like a long pole with a bit of fishing line attached, and then depending on the sitter, you can tie various objects on the end such as furry mouse (for the cat) or a £20 note (for my sister)- to keep them looking where I want them to. I guess I aim it to the left to keep it out of the way of my trigger finger...
|
|
|
AJ Miller
{K:49168} 4/21/2005
|
There's something fascinating happening off to the left - both your model and your cat of several images back seem captivated by it!
Great result - I do appreciate it when photographer's show and explain exactly what they have done.
I think I prefer this one to the B&W - there's a very limited range of tones that add subtlty to the image.
AJ
|
|
|
Frank Beer
{K:10112} 4/20/2005
|
Great portrait, Sally!
I like the light and she has a very nice look :))
Ciao, Frank
|
|
|
Robert Lloyd
{K:9943} 4/20/2005
|
well sally i like it alot lovely face and pose the lightings good to . id say well done
|
|
|
ugur cetin
{K:5895} 4/20/2005
|
really nice.. good work.. congrats..
|
|
|
Sally Morgan
{K:9219} 4/20/2005
|
Here's the original...
|
![](http://thumbs.imageopolis.com/CritiqueImages/3/0/1/0/3010/770721-TN.jpg)
|
|