|
|
Jeroen Wenting
{K:25317} 3/9/2003
|
And whatever you do, don't deface someone elses pictures with comments that are nothing more than a personal attack based on a comment you didn't like.
To me the entire composition, and especially the facial expression of the moden does indeed look more like a corpse than anything angelic.
It's too artificial.
|
|
|
|
|
Ken Alexander
{K:3905} 3/8/2003
|
Interesting idea, but the light areas of the image are too "hot" and lacking in detail.
Jeroen's comment IS constructive, in that it conveys legitimate information about a perception and is not a personal attack. But it's stated much too bluntly, which I guess is what you're reacting to.
|
|
|
|
|
Mike Allebach
{K:391} 3/8/2003
|
It's seemed like constructive criticism to me. I understand Jeroen's point. Don't post pictures that you can't take constructive criticism on.
|
|
|
|
|
Hans-Christian Stoltz
{K:331} 3/8/2003
|
A constructive comment is also what people feel when they look at the image. If Jeroen felt that the photographic angle was kind of strange and what it made him relate to, he just felt it. I don't think he meant something personal towards you, he was just talking about the image. You have to agree on when people from all over the world come together in a place like this, well then we also have a lot of different ways to express ourselves in words. And sometimes words tend to come out the wrong way due to translation problems What he probably meant was that the pose wasn't making him think about angels. I would also like to see more of the models face from a different angle. I would also like to see some arrangements that make me, intuitively, think about angels. The feathers are a nice touch. The tone and the makeup seems also good to me. But like I said a different photograpic angle would probably give more justice to your model and your intentions with this image.
|
|
|
|
|
Rebecca Ann Bunsick
{K:52} 3/8/2003
|
You recently commented on a photo of mine.
"Don't know if it's the angle or what, but it looks to me like a corpse waiting for the people to pay their last respects."
Do you actually think that what you wrote was constructive? Or do you just not know what the word means? You can take your comments elsewhere, because I don't need them. And were you asking is she was an angel or an "angle"?
|
|
|
|
|
Jeroen Wenting
{K:25317} 3/8/2003
|
Don't know if it's the angle or what, but it looks to me like a corpse waiting for the people to pay their last respects.
|
|
0 
